Friday, January 30, 2009

A Varied Mix of Women Writers

Last week, I read a varied mix of women writers: Gertrude Bonnin, Hilda Doolittle, Willa Cather, and Sylvia Plath.

Sioux writer, Gertrude Bonnin, wrote School Days of an Indian Girl and Why I Am a Pagan. School Days of an Indian Girl was entertaining and flowed quickly, but the writing was rather novice. I felt like Bonnin was just trying to show how terribly the whites treated the Indians and it was so one-sided. I was not there and I am white, so therefore I cannot speak for the Indians, but I will say that, while our white ancestors treated the Indians very wrongly, misunderstandings happened on both sides. Yes, the Indians got the worst of it: they lost their lands, lost their identity, all of the treaties were voided, they were cheated. But the Indians did not understand the whites either. From both sides of the line, how do you deal and compromise with a group of people whom you don't understand and who refuse to understand you?
Bonnin recalls her days at boarding school and I just feel like the writing is not up to expectations (but then, she was Indian and perhaps English was her second language, I don't know).
I enjoyed Why I Am a Pagan much more than School Days of an Indian Girl. The language in Why I Am a Pagan was much more beautiful and eloquent than School Days of an Indian Girl, but it still did not pull at my heartstrings nor touch me in a deep way. Although I despise her writing that Christianity is a superstitition, I thought that the beauty and ongoing creation she saw in nature was something wonderful in itself. Are not God and Nature intertwinned, after all?


Whenever I read Hilda Doolittle, I do not bother to understand her. Instead, I just relish the words and images for what they are. Call it lazy, call it dimwitted, but it is what I do. The Dictionary? Chunk it. Symbolism and hidden meanings? Leave it for the birds. Just give me the words.

Willa Cather. Willa Cather. Willa Cather. The Song of the Lark is one of my favorite books. Her story, A Wager Matinee, as like all of her stories, satisfied me, but I thought the plot was rather ordinary. A woman resigned to a dull station in life which is beneath her, becomes transfixed during a musical and at the end, doesn't want to leave. That's been done a thousand, no, a million, times. But it was still enjoyable nonetheless.


Sylvia Plath. The beautiful, troubled Sylvia. I thought her poem "Daddy" was a little harsh. It just bothered me. I really liked "Lady Lazarus;" I saw it as she was dying over and over, but she kept rising as well. The last stanza, "Out of the ash / I rise with my red hair / And I eat men like air." It made me think of a phoenix; a great, gorgeous and hideous bird rising out of dust and then it dies again and then rises again; death and rebirth. There are a thousand ways to die and your heart can still be beating.


So that's the gist of what I read last week. All women writers: an Indian, a Modernist, a country girl, and a troubled soul.














No comments:

Post a Comment