Friday, January 30, 2009

Native Americans and African Americans

This week I focused on Indian and Black writers. I have no reason for this...I just felt like it...is that a good enough reason in itself? For me, it is. I don't feel the need to have logical, eloquent reasons. It makes life so dull.



I really enjoyed Frances Ellen Watkins Harper's poetry. African American Literature is not my favorite genre and I really don't read much of it, but I like Zora Neale Hurston a lot (everyone should read Their Eyes Were Watching God...excellent book), so I thought I'd give Harper a try. "The Martyr of Alabama" and "A Double Standard" were my favorites. "The Martyr of Alabama" is about a black boy who was killed by some white men because he would not dance for them. The boy said that he can't dance because of he was a church member; I'm assuming he was Baptist. It was a very sad poem and Harper pulled it off without making it sound like a pity party. My favorite poem of hers that I read was "A Double Standard." I think she plays on race in this poem, but instead of that, I like how she discusses how hard women fall, whereas men do not. A man can raise a woman up and bring her down just as fast, but a woman cannot do either of those things to a man. It's the whole "fallen woman" theme I believe she has going on in "A Double Standard."

Her essay, "Woman's Political Future" was quite eloquent. Now, I believe in women's equality, but not feminism. There is a difference between equality and feminism. When I voted in the last election (which apparently didn't matter much, since most of America voted the other way, but whatever), I have all the women before me to thank for that. I don't feel like rambling on about my personal views about Feminism now and I will spare you my chaotic rant, so I will end the thought here.



What's not to love about Zora Neale Hurston? I even love that hat she wears and the expression on her face. Well, I read her short story Sweat and througouhly enjoyed it. All of it hasn't quite registered in my brain yet; I'm still digesting it. So with that, I don't have much to say. I feel like in this blog and is the last one, I haven't made much progress in terms of literary feats. I'm just discussing my personal opinion instead of symbolism and meaning. Well, I'll work up to my literary feat. Things come slowly, you know. Except for money: it comes fast and it goes fast. Ok, now I'm just rambling. Anyway, I really enjoyed Sweat...I thought it was wonderful, but I'm still not sure how to take it just yet. It's one of those great stories that you just have to let sit and let it come to you. Like an epiphany. Kind of.



I've never read James Baldwin until now and honestly, I did not think I would like him. But to my amazement, I really liked Sonny's Blues. It was so sad and I really felt for Sonny; I cared about him and the moment you begin to care about a character, you know you're doomed. Sonny was on drugs, didn't hold a real job, couldn't show his love for others, especially his own family, and led a truly tragic life. But I liked him. In real life, I would probably not be his friend or anything, but in the story, I felt so sorry for him. He seemed so real, like an actual person who cannot escape himself. I think that's the crux of Baldwin's story, but in my humble opinion, I'm not sure. The act of escaping yourself'; escaping the things about yourself that you hate.



Sarah Winnemucca reminded me of Gertrude Bonnin. Winnemucca's story Life Among the Piutes used the same techniques that Bonnin used in School Days of an Indian Girl. Her story simply uses narrative voice to describe the horrors inflicted upon the Indians by the whites. But is also made me sad when Winnemucca was describing how the whites raped young Indian girls. I was sad, not for the raping although that is horrific in itself, but rather because it did not shock me. Now that I have gotten to the point where rape does not shock me, it saddens me. I wish I was shocked by murder and rape and the horrific, sick things people do to one another. Sometimes I am shocked, but in this case, I am not. Rapes probably happened all the time back then just as they do now...white men even married Indian girls, so go figure. Gertrude Bonnin and Sarah Winnemucca, please tell me something I don't know.

It was refreshing and exhilirating to read Louise Erdrich and I fell in love. Erdrich's langauge in the excerpt from Love Medicine was absolutely stunning and beautiful. I think it was the words I fell in love with...yes, I am that shallow: to love words more than meanings. I also thought Love Medicine had a lot of substance; it was more than just an bland account of how the whites treated the Indians, but something more than that. Like Hurston, I still haven't digested it all, but I'm working on it. Now I'm just letting the words settle in my humble brain. Erdrich is by far the most eloquently beautiful Indian writer I've read so far. Here are some quotes from Love Medicine:


"So when I went there, I knew the dark fish must rise."


"For she was the definite most-hard trial of anyone's endureance, even when they started out with veils of wretched love upon their eyes."


"Love. The black hook. The spear singing through the mind."


"When I finished that heaven stuff she told me to roll my sleeves up and begin doing God's labor. For a while we worked in silence, mixing up the dough and pounding it out on stone slabs.
'God's work,' I said after a while, 'If this is God's work, then I've done it all my life.'"


"And when your flesh is hot, remember that the flames you feel are only one fraction of the heat you will feel in his hellish embrace."


"Leopolda with her soul like a rubber overboot. With her face of a starved rat. With the desperate eyes drowning in the deep wells of her wrongness...I saw Leopolda kneeling within the shambles of her wrongness."


Absolutely, terribly, wrongly beautiful.






A Varied Mix of Women Writers

Last week, I read a varied mix of women writers: Gertrude Bonnin, Hilda Doolittle, Willa Cather, and Sylvia Plath.

Sioux writer, Gertrude Bonnin, wrote School Days of an Indian Girl and Why I Am a Pagan. School Days of an Indian Girl was entertaining and flowed quickly, but the writing was rather novice. I felt like Bonnin was just trying to show how terribly the whites treated the Indians and it was so one-sided. I was not there and I am white, so therefore I cannot speak for the Indians, but I will say that, while our white ancestors treated the Indians very wrongly, misunderstandings happened on both sides. Yes, the Indians got the worst of it: they lost their lands, lost their identity, all of the treaties were voided, they were cheated. But the Indians did not understand the whites either. From both sides of the line, how do you deal and compromise with a group of people whom you don't understand and who refuse to understand you?
Bonnin recalls her days at boarding school and I just feel like the writing is not up to expectations (but then, she was Indian and perhaps English was her second language, I don't know).
I enjoyed Why I Am a Pagan much more than School Days of an Indian Girl. The language in Why I Am a Pagan was much more beautiful and eloquent than School Days of an Indian Girl, but it still did not pull at my heartstrings nor touch me in a deep way. Although I despise her writing that Christianity is a superstitition, I thought that the beauty and ongoing creation she saw in nature was something wonderful in itself. Are not God and Nature intertwinned, after all?


Whenever I read Hilda Doolittle, I do not bother to understand her. Instead, I just relish the words and images for what they are. Call it lazy, call it dimwitted, but it is what I do. The Dictionary? Chunk it. Symbolism and hidden meanings? Leave it for the birds. Just give me the words.

Willa Cather. Willa Cather. Willa Cather. The Song of the Lark is one of my favorite books. Her story, A Wager Matinee, as like all of her stories, satisfied me, but I thought the plot was rather ordinary. A woman resigned to a dull station in life which is beneath her, becomes transfixed during a musical and at the end, doesn't want to leave. That's been done a thousand, no, a million, times. But it was still enjoyable nonetheless.


Sylvia Plath. The beautiful, troubled Sylvia. I thought her poem "Daddy" was a little harsh. It just bothered me. I really liked "Lady Lazarus;" I saw it as she was dying over and over, but she kept rising as well. The last stanza, "Out of the ash / I rise with my red hair / And I eat men like air." It made me think of a phoenix; a great, gorgeous and hideous bird rising out of dust and then it dies again and then rises again; death and rebirth. There are a thousand ways to die and your heart can still be beating.


So that's the gist of what I read last week. All women writers: an Indian, a Modernist, a country girl, and a troubled soul.














Little Thoughts on Excuses...and Shakespeare (and yes, I know he was not American)


This blog doesn't have much to do with American Lit, but I thought I'd throw it out there anyway. On Monday, Professor Hepworth asked me what books I'm currently reading. I read lots of books over the summer and over Christmas break, I read 3 books. Well, since school started, I haven't really read anything not required and I told Hepworth that I didn't have time, because of all the required reading I have do for classes. Hey, I'm an English major...I really do have to read a lot!

Well, just the other day, on Tuesday, my friend told me that she doesn't have time to clean her house. I was completely shocked. Don't have time to clean? Cleaning is a basic neccessity and something you just have to do. Don't get me wrong; she's a great person...I wouldn't be friends with her if I didn't like her, now would I? So that got me thinking. My friend is married, is an English major as well, and only works 2 or 3 hours a day. (Again, she's a very nice person and I'm not trying to pick on her). But she can't find time to clean? If I can find time to get all my homework/reading done for 5 English classes, work out for 2 hours in the gym 4-5 days a week (I lift weights, not run on a treadmill), cook dinner just about every night (my fiance helps out sometimes), and clean every single day, I think I can find time to read a book. So I'm done with my excuses.

Therefore, I picked up a book. It's called My Father had a Daughter by Grace Tiffany. I haven't gotten very far yet (only chapter 2), but it's very good. It's about Judith Shakespeare, the daughter of...guess who? William Shakespeare! It's supposed to be kind of historical, but given the scant information about Judith Shakespeare, most of it is fictionalized. It reads quickly, flows right through, and is very fascinating.

Here's what is says on the book jacket:

"William Shakespeare was father to three children: Susanna, his oldest, and twins Judith and Hamnet. This is Judith's tale...
Growing up in Stratford-upon-Avon, Judith and her twin brother, Hamnet, see little of their father. His visits are infrequent, and they know him only as "the scribbling one." Bit by bit, however, he begins to share with them his poetry of star-crossed lovers, a jailed English king, a murderous moneylender, a fairy queen. By the edge of the River Avon, the twins devise games based on their father's wondrous poetry to entertain each other whenever he is away.
Then, after a dark family tragedy, young Judith happens on a scrap copy of her father's newest play, left behind in his haste to return to London. She reads it, and is shocked to find it a comic treatment of her family's grief, especially her own. Outraged, she follows her father to London with an audacious plan to sabotage the play's first performance. But the city is a revelation to her, as is her father's world of the theater, and his new playhouse, the Globe. As Judith comes fully to understand the words her father has written, and why he writes his plays, she discovers that the two of them share more than she could have possiblity imagined."

So my excuses are done and when I get home from the gym and finish cooking dinner, I plan on sitting back in a chair with tea (I'm an avid tea drinker...I have 3 or so cups a day...it's great stuff) and read My Father had a Daughter.

Happy reading. :-)

Wednesday, January 28, 2009

Why I Have a Problem with Hemingway



For the record, I am not judging Hemingway himself, but rather, his work. A part of me feels like I am in no position to judge his work, considering how he is a great American writer and a pioneer of the short story. Hemingway has made a wonderful contribution to American literature and I completely respect the man, but I have to lay some issues about his work on the table.




I have read the book and seen the movie. And honestly, neither one made much of an impact on me. A Farewell to Arms irked me because the characters were so bland, so ordinary, so undeveloped, especially Catherine. The man is the head of the house and I think it's wonderful that she loved him so much, but her love for Henry overshadowed her personality. Catherine plays a critical and important role in the story and (in my opinion), her personality doesn't shine enough. She is a perfect woman. And that is completely unrealistic. I don't know any perfect women, including myself. Furthermore, she is a woman in love during wartime. That makes for an astounding story, but I just feel that Catherine doesn't rise to her full character in A Farewell to Arms. If the story was told from Catherine's point of view (along with more emotion in the book overall), A Farewell to Arms would drastically change and personally, I think it would be more interesting. When I open the pages of a love story, I expect the story to rise to it's full height. After all, it is a love story and it must rise and fall like tragic love often does. One thing I do like about A Farewell to Arms is the rain. Catherine confesses that she's afraid of the rain and then at the very end, she dies during the childbirth in the rain. The image the book leaves you with is beautiful, but everything else (in my biased opinion) doesn't live up to its potential.




Hills Like White Elephants centers on abortion. An American man is trying to convince his girlfriend, "Jig," to have an abortion. I strongly dislike the American man and Jig, both of them. The man is being unreasonably selfish and is asking Jig to do a very hard, tough thing. Of course this has nothing to do with Hemingway; it's just something he wrote about. So again, I'm not judging Hemingway. Hills Like White Elephants is extremely sad and tragic: a father's wish to be rid of his own child and a mother who is unable to protect her baby. Towards the end, Jig kept saying that she didn't want to talk about it anymore. By this, she is unable to handle the situation and make up her mind about the abortion. A parent's first responsiblity is to protect his or her child. Both parents in this story are not doing that and this is what makes Hills Like White Elephants so tragic.



I'll be honest here: A Clean, Well-Lighted Place really confused me the first time I read it. The last paragraph bothered me as well, when one of the characters was reciting The Lord's Prayer while inserting "nothing" and "nada" in it. After this, Hemingway writes, "Hail nothing full of nothing, nothing is with thee." I still don't quite get it and I doubt I ever will, but the story, especially the ending just does not sit well with me for reasons beyond what I can explain.

So that's my take on Ernest Hemingway's work. Not the man, but his work.




Wednesday, January 21, 2009

Reading List


There are many stories I love, but I would have to say that I'm always finding myself falling for love stories. Mind you, not paperback Harlequin romances, where a man meets a woman, they have a passionate love affair, they get into some kind of stupid drama, and then the ride off into the sunset together to live happily ever after, yadda yadda yadda. Those romances are completely empty, lacking any kind of meaningful substance, like Harry Potter and Twilight (which I will not go into so not to waste your precious time reading a rant about how I want to burn Twilight). I don't read by author (although there are some that I am loyal to, which I will explain later), but I read a book based on my interest in it more so than who wrote it.
The greatest book ever written (of course, in my opinion) is Wuthering Heights by Emily Bronte. It's love at its highest, its greatest. And you know, from the very beginning, that the characters are doomed because of their love. It's one of the few tragic love stories (along with Romeo and Juliet) that actually ascends to its full height. Love is what binds Heathcliff and Cathy and it is what ultimately destroys them (but in a quite unusual way). Instead of dying like Romeo or moving past his failed love, but always carrying it with him, instead, Heathcliff self-destructs. He destroys himself and the lives around him all because of doomed love. Also, the language is gorgeous, such as when Heathcliff exclaims to Cathy, "Kiss me again, but don't let me see your eyes! I forgive what you have done to me. I love my murderer--but yours! How can I?" Cathy also delivers beautiful lines, "If all else perished, and he remained, I should still continue to be; and if all else remained, and he were annihilated, the universe would turn to a mighty stranger: I should not seem a part of it...Nelly, I am Heathcliff! He's always, always in my mind: not as a pleasure, any more than I am always a pleasure to myself, but as my own being." How can you not love those lines?! I made my fiance watch the movie (which follows the book very closely), and needless to say, he was not too impressed. His take on the story, is that it is selfish love created by selfless people overdramatizing everyone. I suppose he does have a point; both Heathcliff and Cathy are very selfish individuals, but no one can deny the beauty of the language and the summits that Wuthering Heights rises to.
As for authors, I'm loyal to Philippa Gregory. I have read and own many of her books and have fallen in love. Many of her books focus on the Tudor House of England (think Henry VIII, Anne Boleyn, Elizabeth I) and I find that time period fascinating. It is amazing how much Henry VIII, all because of his selfishness and lust, ended up changing the entire world so drastically. His divorce from Catherine of Aragon sparked a major reformation that still haunts England today. He separated England from the Pope (a huge deal back them), declared himself the head of England, allowed for divorce, gave birth to the Espiscopal Church, was the father of one of England's bloodiest women (Mary I), and also the father of Queen Elizabeth I (whom he never really claimed) who made England a Prostantent nation and helped the arts rise (Shakespeare lived and wrote during her reign). And all this because of one selfish, lustful man who couldn't remain faithful to his wife and desperately wanted a male heir. It's absolutely fascinating history, and Gregory does a wonderful job of portraying acutal historical events of time along with creative writing thrown in. My favorite books of hers include: The Other Boleyn Girl (which is now a movie! which I totally recommend), The Constant Princess, The Virgin's Lover (you can't tell me that doesn't sound good!), and The Boleyn Inheritance.

When I was a little girl, my favorite book was The Giving Tree by Shel Silverstein. It's a beautiful story about a tree who gives and gives and gives to this boy as he grows from childhood into adulthood, and finally into old age. It's a wonderful story about love, giving, and self-sacrifice. It also reads like poetry in a way.

I'm not a fan of scary/horror stuff in books or movies. In movies, I just get terrified and creeped out, and I don't like it. In horror books, I don't get scared, just weirded out and it leaves me with a horrible feeling, which again, I don't like. So, in short, I avoid stories about haunted houses, ghosts, murders, torture, giant cockroaches, and the like. I don't like the feelings those kinds of stories leave me with. It also leaves me to wonder: what was the point of that? Needless to say, I do not spend a lot of time reading Franz Kafta or Edgar Allan Poe (although I love Annabel Lee and The Raven).


I know how cheesy this is going to sound, but I'm a diehearted Little Mermaid fan. Yes, it was my favorite movie as a kid and to this day, it's still my favorite movie (along with Shakespeare in Love). I read (and also own) The Little Mermaid by Hans Christian Andersen. The Disney movie is not like the original story, so don't expect anything out of the movie. The story by Andersen, is just absolutely beautiful, for both language and content. At the end, instead of killing the prince so she can become a mermaid again, she flings herself overboard into the ocean to become foam on the waves. Despite how it's a fairy tale, The Little Mermaid (the story by Andersen) is a simple story about the ultimate self-sacrifice. Wuthering Heights focuses on self-destruction, whereas The Little Mermaid centers around self-sacrifice. Both consequences are brought on by love.


As for authors, I greatly admire Willa Cather. I love The Song of the Lark and My Antonia. I deeply appreciate how Cather focuses her stories (at least the ones that I have read) around land. She knows what is means to grow up in a rural society and the attachment people can hold to the land. Sometimes, it's as if the land acts, not as place, but as a true being in itself, which it is. And the bond that you can have with a chunk of land is unlike anything else in the world. I feel that Cather, more so than any other writer I have read, touches on this the most.

So there you have it. I'm a hopeless romantic who could fall in love with a poem and marry a novel. ;-)










The Real Emily Dickinson?

There is only one positively identified photograph of Emily Dickinson, believed to be taken when she was sixteen years old in 1846. Another photograph has been found, sparking a debate over whether or not it really is Emily Dickinson. The questionable photograph is believed to have been taken around 1853, leaving Dickinson at age 33. The sepia photograph cannot be the famous poet for several reasons, including physical appearance, her letters to T.W. Higginson, the death of her friend, and logical reasons based on what is known about her personality and lifestyle.
Granted, many people can change drastically over a period of 17 years, but these changes do not generally mean a shortening of the neck, a rounding of face, and a completely different posture. There are many differences between the two photographs both believed to be Emily Dickinson, leaving the only similarities to be the hair (what the viewer can actually see of her hair, given that it is tied back behind her head in a supposed bun), the eyebrows and the eyes. The hairdo is quite simple and would not be hard to copy. Given how the photographs are not in color, the viewer cannot determine the exact shade of both women’s hair, except that they both have dark hair.
The woman in the questionable photograph appears shorter than Dickinson, both in height and neck. Dickinson’s neck is longer and more slender than the other woman’s.
Judging the distance between the top of the tables and the tip of both women’s heads, the real Dickinson seems to be taller. It is possible for the tables to be slightly different heights, but most tables are generally the same amount of feet tall. The questionable, sepia woman has thinner lips, a shorter forehead, a rounder face, a different nose, and is slouching more. As for the similar positions of their hands, it is a very common way to position oneself with a table and a chair and it could also be considered “formal” for its time. Dickinson’s face is longer, more heart-shaped than the other woman’s, whose cheeks jut out sideways and completely lacks a heart-shaped structure to her face.
The questionable woman appears disconnected with the camera, as if she’s off in some other world, whereas Dickinson seems to be engaged and focusing on the camera. In her early thirties, around the same time that the questionable photograph was taken, Dickinson developed an eye problem, which could account somewhat for the lack of connection in the sepia photograph. But, despite this, it had to be more than just an eye problem, especially with a woman so full of personality and intelligence.
But it is not just appearances that mark a difference between the two women, leading the second woman not to be Emily Dickinson. More evidence can be found in her personal letters. Such as, in a letter to T.W. Higginson, Dickinson writes,
“Could you believe me—without? I had no portrait, now, but a small, like the Wren, and my Hair is bold, like the Chestnut Bur—and my eyes, like the Sherry in the Glass, that the Guest leaves—Would this do just as well?”
First of all, she claimed not to have a portrait. She wrote this letter in July 1862, approximately ten years after her alleged photograph. Back in her day, having a
photograph taken was a huge deal, as is took quite awhile (half an hour or so) just to take the photograph. Besides, not many people had their photographs taken. It does not seem possible, especially for such an intelligent woman, to have forgotten her photograph from only ten years prior. Another factor is that she could be lying, but what is the point of lying about such a thing as a photograph? Granted, she could have wanted to keep the photograph private, away from prying eyes, which would account for the lie, but then, if that was the case, why even take the photograph?
Dickinson describes her appearance using words, not visual mediums, such as photographs. When she writes, “Would this do just as well?” what she means is, “Would my words do justice to a photograph?” With that statement inside of a question, she is claiming that words can do just as good a job describing someone or something than a picture or a photograph can. For a woman who had such a strong faith in words, it does not make sense that she would go through all the hassle of getting herself photographed, when she could just write about herself instead.
In March of 1853, Dickinson’s dear friend Benjamin Newton died of tuberculosis. His death would have occurred early in the same year that Dickinson had her photograph taken. With Newton’s death, came Dickinson’s sudden illness which plagued her for months. Unless the photograph was taken before this tragic incident or late in year, she, being ill, would probably not have gotten up to be photographed.
Emily Dickinson’s most productive years were between 1858 and 1865, shortly after her supposed second photograph. It would have been during these years that she would have gotten the most serious about her work, delving into her poetry and attaining
the persona of being a secluded hermit. Also, it is believed that from her mid/late twenties and onward until her death, she only wore white. It can never be proved when exactly she started wearing white or how often she wore white, but the ounce of truth that is evident is that Dickinson did wear white later in her life, and in the sepia photograph, taken in her thirties, she is certainly not wearing white.
It is with these thoughts in mind, which leads me to the conclusion that the woman in the mysterious photograph is not Emily Dickinson. There are a lot of people who look a like and neither one of the photographs are in color. So the mysterious photograph is a picture of a woman who could fool the viewers into thinking she was the quiet, secluded poet from Amherst.