Monday, May 4, 2009

Barn Burning

1. How do Americans typically establish individual independence as teenagers? Do you remember any crucial moment in your own life when you realized that you had to make a choice between what your parent(s) and/or family believed and your own values?
American teens usually rebel against their parents, which I think is rather ironic. Almost every teenager wants approval from their parents, but they still rebel anyway. Teens are stuck in limbo between finding independence/their own values and approval/love from their parents. It's a catch-22.

2. Is the destruction of another person's property ever something we can justify? Explain.
No. I don't want to sound prejudice against anyone, but in today's society, it's usually the lower class kids who vandalize and steal. This is their parents' fault. Completely. They don't own anything, so therefore, they don't know the value of something. And their parents never taught them. I grew up on a farm in the middle of nowhere and I would never, ever, vandalize anyone else's property. I wouldn't want someone doing that to me and I understand how important land is to people who own it. Besides, the old saying is: two wrongs don't make a right! Why stoop to someone else's level to get back at them? It's a child's game. And a person's property is just something that you don't ever mess with. So, I don't know what else to say about it, except for the answer is a big, resounding NO.

3. Does it matter that this story is rendered through Sarty's consciousness? What were Faulkner's options, and how would the story be different if he had exercised them?
This story is strongest when it's by Sarty. The wife is on Abner's side; she has no choice. The sisters don't seem all that bright or conflicted, or really, anything. Sarty, unlike the rest of the characters--and also since he is a boy--must make a choice between his father and his own values. If this story was told by the sister's P.O.V., it would be completely different, because the relationship a girl has with her father is compeltely different than that of a son. Abner is his daughter's first love and hero and should set an example of how men ought to treat them. But with Sarty, his father is certainly not this, but instead, a figure to look up to, to model after. And this changes the story drastically. "Barn Burning" must be told through Sarty's consciousness, because that is the only way it will work as a story about a boy rejecting the father/masculine figure he is supposed to model himself after.

4. What are the key symbols in the story, and how do they serve the thematic purposes Faulkner had in mind?
Fire is obviously a huge symbol. Abner is full of rage and hate, so in a way, he parellels the fire. Out-of-control rage and destruction. The fire could also represent the burning of Abner's values; the concrete image of rejection by his son. And like the fire that forever destroys the barn, there will always be a rift between Abner and Sarty. It can never be fully healed.
I also think that rug Abner steps on symbolizes something. It's a beautiful rug and Abner immediately, upon seeing it, dirties it. He wipes his filthy feet on it. This is very disrespectful and shows how Abner treats, not just things, but the people who own them: they are fit for the dirt on his boot.

5. Do the class issues the story raises have any parallels today?
Yes. There will always be class issues. I can't think of anything specific right now; I think it's getting too late at night!

6. What is the tone of the story, and how is it established.
Faulkner's voice is very poetic, but amid this poetry, it is dark. Darkly poetic. This is all I have to say!

Writing assignment (blogs): Choose a short story from the Modern period that you like and then explain why you like it. For instance, you might like the humor in a particular story, the method the author uses to characterize an individual, or a particular character or the way the author depicts a particular period in history, and so on.

I really like Sherwood Anderson's "A Death in the Woods." Anderson's comes off as a storyteller more so than a narrator. The very first line is, "She was an old woman and lived on a farm near the town in which I lived." He is going to tell us about his neighbor and automatically we believe him and continue reading the story. His voice is authorative, which makes his story more believeable.
I also like his language. It's smooth and lacks confusion, while at the same time, not dumbing down the reader. It is simple.
I mostly loved Mrs. Grimes. Life was not kind to her, but she still kept trudging on in the woods just to feed everyone. I think that her devotion to finding people and animals, which leads to her death, and how even in death she continued to feed others, means a lot more under the surface; more than what I'm getting. This is mostly what makes the story so captivating; this poor woman's devotion to feeding others instead of herself. And it kills her. I think Anderson is being very subtle, leaving so much more going on underneath the written words.

Podcast

So over the weekend, I made 2 podcasts. Since I had major difficulty posting them here, I just put them on a CD. Reciting this poems took me FOREVER! I started around 10 or so and didn't finish until 4 in the morning. My finace recorded me and he was a big help. But, I wasn't satisfied with my voice along with worries about reading too fast or too slow, misprouncing things, etc. But, I finished it! So, although you all can't listen to it on here, I thought I'd post the poems I recited/recorded on here anyway.

The first one was an Emily Dickinson poem. Go figure? :)

I have no life but this,
To lead it here;
Nor any death, but lest
Dispelled from there;

Nor tie to earths to come,
Nor action new,
Except through this extent,
The realm of you.
I just love this poem!

The second poem was "The Letter" by Amy Lowell.

Little cramped words scrawling all over the paper
Like draggled fly's legs,
What can you tell of the flaring moon
Through the oak leaves?
Or of my uncurtained window and the bare floor
Spattered with moonlight?
Your silly quirks and twists have nothing in them
Of blossoming hawthorns,
And this paper is dull, crisp, smooth, virgin of loveliness
Beneath my hand.

I am tired, Beloved, of chafing my heart against
The want of you;
Of squeezing it into little inkdrops,
And posting it.
And I scald alone, here, under the fire
Of the great moon.

Imagine my voice saying these words. And that's what I did over the weekend.

Friday, May 1, 2009

Louise Erdrich







So I just finished reading Louise Erdrich's novel Four Souls and it was wondeful. I'm now plowing through Love Medicine, which is equally just as good. I'm also currently writing a paper about how water functions in Tracks. Tracks, Four Souls, and Love Medicine are all part of a trilology (in that respected chronological order) which follows several generations of some families: the Lazarres, Morrisseys, and Pillagers. Most of the characters are Chippewa Indians (the Ojibwe tribe from the Great Lakes region and North Dakota). Erdrich herself is Chippewa from her mother's side and German from her father's. Her husband's name is Michael Dorris (he's a writer as well) and they have a houseful of children. Erdrich has a compelling, poetic voice that never gets old. I'm almost halfway through Love Medicine right now. So, if you have any spare time this summer or just want to delve into a good book which has substance, I recommend these books. I think Erdrich has something like 11 novels, but I've only read these three, so therefore I'm only giving my opinion on these three. :) Most of her books are in the library here at school and are easy to find. It's good reading. :)