
For the record, I am not judging Hemingway himself, but rather, his work. A part of me feels like I am in no position to judge his work, considering how he is a great American writer and a pioneer of the short story. Hemingway has made a wonderful contribution to American literature and I completely respect the man, but I have to lay some issues about his work on the table.

I have read the book and seen the movie. And honestly, neither one made much of an impact on me. A Farewell to Arms irked me because the characters were so bland, so ordinary, so undeveloped, especially Catherine. The man is the head of the house and I think it's wonderful that she loved him so much, but her love for Henry overshadowed her personality. Catherine plays a critical and important role in the story and (in my opinion), her personality doesn't shine enough. She is a perfect woman. And that is completely unrealistic. I don't know any perfect women, including myself. Furthermore, she is a woman in love during wartime. That makes for an astounding story, but I just feel that Catherine doesn't rise to her full character in A Farewell to Arms. If the story was told from Catherine's point of view (along with more emotion in the book overall), A Farewell to Arms would drastically change and personally, I think it would be more interesting. When I open the pages of a love story, I expect the story to rise to it's full height. After all, it is a love story and it must rise and fall like tragic love often does. One thing I do like about A Farewell to Arms is the rain. Catherine confesses that she's afraid of the rain and then at the very end, she dies during the childbirth in the rain. The image the book leaves you with is beautiful, but everything else (in my biased opinion) doesn't live up to its potential.

Hills Like White Elephants centers on abortion. An American man is trying to convince his girlfriend, "Jig," to have an abortion. I strongly dislike the American man and Jig, both of them. The man is being unreasonably selfish and is asking Jig to do a very hard, tough thing. Of course this has nothing to do with Hemingway; it's just something he wrote about. So again, I'm not judging Hemingway. Hills Like White Elephants is extremely sad and tragic: a father's wish to be rid of his own child and a mother who is unable to protect her baby. Towards the end, Jig kept saying that she didn't want to talk about it anymore. By this, she is unable to handle the situation and make up her mind about the abortion. A parent's first responsiblity is to protect his or her child. Both parents in this story are not doing that and this is what makes Hills Like White Elephants so tragic.

I'll be honest here: A Clean, Well-Lighted Place really confused me the first time I read it. The last paragraph bothered me as well, when one of the characters was reciting The Lord's Prayer while inserting "nothing" and "nada" in it. After this, Hemingway writes, "Hail nothing full of nothing, nothing is with thee." I still don't quite get it and I doubt I ever will, but the story, especially the ending just does not sit well with me for reasons beyond what I can explain.
So that's my take on Ernest Hemingway's work. Not the man, but his work.
Many women seem to dislike Hemingway for the same reasons you do, but his master of the craft makes him worth re-reading. My goal is to say things in as few words as he, Raymond Carver, and Cormac McCarthy have done, though I doubt it will ever happen.
ReplyDeleteThough I haven't read Clean Well Lighted Place, I can guess what the ending means. If you think about it a little more, I'd be curious what you come up with. Tell me next time you see me.