Wednesday, January 21, 2009

The Real Emily Dickinson?

There is only one positively identified photograph of Emily Dickinson, believed to be taken when she was sixteen years old in 1846. Another photograph has been found, sparking a debate over whether or not it really is Emily Dickinson. The questionable photograph is believed to have been taken around 1853, leaving Dickinson at age 33. The sepia photograph cannot be the famous poet for several reasons, including physical appearance, her letters to T.W. Higginson, the death of her friend, and logical reasons based on what is known about her personality and lifestyle.
Granted, many people can change drastically over a period of 17 years, but these changes do not generally mean a shortening of the neck, a rounding of face, and a completely different posture. There are many differences between the two photographs both believed to be Emily Dickinson, leaving the only similarities to be the hair (what the viewer can actually see of her hair, given that it is tied back behind her head in a supposed bun), the eyebrows and the eyes. The hairdo is quite simple and would not be hard to copy. Given how the photographs are not in color, the viewer cannot determine the exact shade of both women’s hair, except that they both have dark hair.
The woman in the questionable photograph appears shorter than Dickinson, both in height and neck. Dickinson’s neck is longer and more slender than the other woman’s.
Judging the distance between the top of the tables and the tip of both women’s heads, the real Dickinson seems to be taller. It is possible for the tables to be slightly different heights, but most tables are generally the same amount of feet tall. The questionable, sepia woman has thinner lips, a shorter forehead, a rounder face, a different nose, and is slouching more. As for the similar positions of their hands, it is a very common way to position oneself with a table and a chair and it could also be considered “formal” for its time. Dickinson’s face is longer, more heart-shaped than the other woman’s, whose cheeks jut out sideways and completely lacks a heart-shaped structure to her face.
The questionable woman appears disconnected with the camera, as if she’s off in some other world, whereas Dickinson seems to be engaged and focusing on the camera. In her early thirties, around the same time that the questionable photograph was taken, Dickinson developed an eye problem, which could account somewhat for the lack of connection in the sepia photograph. But, despite this, it had to be more than just an eye problem, especially with a woman so full of personality and intelligence.
But it is not just appearances that mark a difference between the two women, leading the second woman not to be Emily Dickinson. More evidence can be found in her personal letters. Such as, in a letter to T.W. Higginson, Dickinson writes,
“Could you believe me—without? I had no portrait, now, but a small, like the Wren, and my Hair is bold, like the Chestnut Bur—and my eyes, like the Sherry in the Glass, that the Guest leaves—Would this do just as well?”
First of all, she claimed not to have a portrait. She wrote this letter in July 1862, approximately ten years after her alleged photograph. Back in her day, having a
photograph taken was a huge deal, as is took quite awhile (half an hour or so) just to take the photograph. Besides, not many people had their photographs taken. It does not seem possible, especially for such an intelligent woman, to have forgotten her photograph from only ten years prior. Another factor is that she could be lying, but what is the point of lying about such a thing as a photograph? Granted, she could have wanted to keep the photograph private, away from prying eyes, which would account for the lie, but then, if that was the case, why even take the photograph?
Dickinson describes her appearance using words, not visual mediums, such as photographs. When she writes, “Would this do just as well?” what she means is, “Would my words do justice to a photograph?” With that statement inside of a question, she is claiming that words can do just as good a job describing someone or something than a picture or a photograph can. For a woman who had such a strong faith in words, it does not make sense that she would go through all the hassle of getting herself photographed, when she could just write about herself instead.
In March of 1853, Dickinson’s dear friend Benjamin Newton died of tuberculosis. His death would have occurred early in the same year that Dickinson had her photograph taken. With Newton’s death, came Dickinson’s sudden illness which plagued her for months. Unless the photograph was taken before this tragic incident or late in year, she, being ill, would probably not have gotten up to be photographed.
Emily Dickinson’s most productive years were between 1858 and 1865, shortly after her supposed second photograph. It would have been during these years that she would have gotten the most serious about her work, delving into her poetry and attaining
the persona of being a secluded hermit. Also, it is believed that from her mid/late twenties and onward until her death, she only wore white. It can never be proved when exactly she started wearing white or how often she wore white, but the ounce of truth that is evident is that Dickinson did wear white later in her life, and in the sepia photograph, taken in her thirties, she is certainly not wearing white.
It is with these thoughts in mind, which leads me to the conclusion that the woman in the mysterious photograph is not Emily Dickinson. There are a lot of people who look a like and neither one of the photographs are in color. So the mysterious photograph is a picture of a woman who could fool the viewers into thinking she was the quiet, secluded poet from Amherst.

1 comment:

  1. We—I—missed the deep quiet your absence sang—
    misplaced by You from when you last took your place and placed yourself elsewhere. Your singing here
    reminds me of that absent tune. Present or absent
    we both know there is no quiet so quiet as the quiet birds make when they take the air. I'm glad I found you here.

    ReplyDelete