Sunday, February 8, 2009

The Great Duel: Whitman vs. Dickinson

What if Walt Whitman and Emily Dickinson got into a duel? How would it all go down? I bet Whitman would be all long-winded and never stop talking. He would also be repititious and make his point a thousand times again and again. But what would Emily do? Would she sit there quietly, allowing her silence to rise above him. Would her silence automatically make her superior to him? Or rather, would Emily retaliate back, standing her ground? She is often seen as shrinking violet, which would incline one to think that she would be quiet. But then again, she could choose to be silent just to shut Whitman down. How do you argue against silence? Sometimes (and I personally think Emily would have known this) silence speaks louder than words. But then, on the flip side, Emily was not a submissive little girl; she had her own views and ideas about everything. What do you think she would've done?

I'd so totally turn off American Idol to watch Whitman vs. Dickinson!

3 comments:

  1. Oooh, that reminds me of a show that used to be on MTV called Celebrity Deathmatch, did you ever see that show? Ha ha, I would definitely watch them duke it out! I think Dickinson would use flowery language to fight him with kindness, when and if she could get a word in edge-wise. Whitman would try to talk circles around her with his giant words that sometimes don't seem to really mean anything, but would be frustrated because, like you said, she'd choose her words carefully and they'd be few and far between.

    I remember when I was sixteen and my mom and I would fight--my mom would just ignore me, sometimes for weeks if it was necessary and it would totally break me :)

    ReplyDelete
  2. I think I've seen bits and pieces of that show. Didn't they have two celebrities (the show was animated or somehting like that) in a boxing arena and outlandish (and bloody) things would happen?

    I love what you think would happen! Dickinson would be all nice and use flowery languge while Whitman would just ramble on and get annoying after awhile!

    By the way, my mom does the whole silent treatment thing too. I just learned to shove it right back at her. Hey, I am pro at being silent! ;-)

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think Whitman would apall Dickinson so much that she would be shocked into silence. Whitman was a pretty big windbag and liked to talk himself up so I think he would have no problem rambling on while Emily silently fumed. Then she would go home and write about what an idiot Whitman was in one of her letters...Oh wait but she did! She said she was told of Whitman but never read his book but was also told he was disgraceful. I don't think Emily would even have stood in his presence...she would have left him amid his rambling.

    ReplyDelete