I've already read Charlotte Perkins Gilman's "The Yellow Wallpaper," so instead I read "Turned." And just as she so very much pleased me with "The Yellow Wallpaper," Gilman failed to disappoint me with "Turned." The story sucked me in and was a real page-turner, but I love the most about it was that like its title, it really did turn. Gilman plays with the norm, the expected, and what she delivers in her story is completely unexpected, but totally believable. In short, "Turned" is about a man who cheats on his wife with their servant. The wife, Mrs. Marooner, is a very educated, sophisficated lady, while their servant, Gerta, is an uneducated, rather dull Swedish girl. Gerta is very sweet, but doesn't have much personality and is very naive when it comes to men. So Mr. Marooner has an affair with Gerta and Mrs. Marooner finds out. I was expecting Mrs. Marooner to cast Gerta out of her home and live out the rest of her life in a miserable marriage. But instead, when Mr. Marooner gets home, he can't find his wife or Gerta anywhere. And at the very end, when he finds them, they are living alone together, Mrs. Marooner is teaching school, and Gerta is holding a baby. The women, both victimized by the same man, banded together and ended up supporting each other. At the very end, his wife asks him what he has to say to them. Needless to say, it was powerful. Another thing I liked about "Turned," was that the husband was afraid to search for his wife, because of embarrassment. I understand that he's embarrassed, but I was hoping that he would love his wife enough to quickly overcome his embarrassment and do anything he could to find her. But he didn't. So, in short, the women turned against him. And the expected outcome was turned upside down.
My favorite Stephen Crane story that I read in the book was "The Bride Comes to Yellow Sky." And I explained in another blog why I love that story, so I'm not going to explain it again here. Honestly, I thought his other stories were a bit boring. I know that sounds horrible to call someone's work boring, but I just couldn't for the life of me get into it. I really did try, though. Honest. Years ago I read some of The Red Badge of Courage, but couldn't really get into it. Maybe I don't like reading about war, just like I don't like watching war movies. I'm not a hippie or anything like that, but it just isn't my thing. He's a fine writer, though. I have nothing to complain about with his writing. As for his poems, they haven't completely sunk it yet, especially "God Lay Dead in Heaven" and "War is Kind." I really don't get "War is Kind." It totally baffles me. So that's all I have to say about it. I'm baffled. If you have any opinion, any opinion whatsoever, about Crane's poetry, especially "War is Kind" I would love to hear it.
I really enjoyed Sherwood Anderson's stories. I read "Hands" and "Death in the Woods." I love how his stories have such a storytelling vibe. In his little bio provided in the book, it calls him a storyteller, but once I read his stories, I could really see it. Or rather, hear it, especially with "Death in the Woods." His prose draws heavily upon oral tradition and storytelling, which is new and refreshing for the mainstream American stories, I think. At least the ones that I've read, not counting black and Indian stories. On the surface, "Hands" was simply about hands. I know there's more to it and it partly makes sense in my head, but I don't think I could put it down in comprehensible words. You know what I mean? Maybe when the words come to me, I'll write them down later. "Death in the Woods" made more sense than "Hands," especially in paper. It is a simple story about a woman who spends her whole life feeding others and she dies walking home to feed the animals, her husband, and her son. She was very thin, half-starved. No one ever fed her. It is such a simple thing, to fed someone, but to her, it was her life, her duty. And it became much greater than just a duty. Her duty, no matter how miserable, how small, rose above all that. I think the story also has to do with how Old Woman Grime kept giving herself over and over again. She fed and fed and fed. And she never got anything back. And then she ended up giving too much that it killed her. It's a beautiful story about self-sacrifice. I also find it interesting that when she died, she looked like a young girl instead of the old woman that she was. Maybe her physical body was a representation of her inner beauty, her self sacrifice? That sounds kind of cheesy, but it's all I've got. In short, it was a wondrously fascinating (and terribly sad) story that left me wondering.
Meridel LeSueur's story "Women on the Breadlines" came off as a social commentary about women and employment during LeSueur's time. The picture LeSueur paints of women trying to get employment is a grim one. She focuses on certain women, telling bits of their stories. A lot of the women in the story refuse to marry, which is kind of weird. Back then, didn't security come with marriage? And wasn't there some social stigma attached to unmarried women, just as there is today? No woman wants to be called an Old Maid. LeSueur writes, "She wants to get married but she sees what happens to her married friends, left with children, worn out before their time. So she stays single. She is virtuous" (p. 1792). Or course she has to mention that the woman is "virtuous." Just to clairfy things. LeSueur also writes, "A womanw ill shut herself up in a room until it is taken from her, and eat a crakcer a day and be as quiet as a mouse so there are no social statistics concerning her. I don's know why it is, but a woman will do this unless she has dependents, will go for weeks verging on starvation...until she becomes too super-sensitive and timid to even ask for a job" (p. 1731). Women are tougher than people think they are. Maybe shy and timid, unsure of ourselves, but tough. That's all I've got to say about that. LeSueur writes more, "A woman always asks a man for help. Rarely another woman." Well, it is simple. Men will take care of them. After all, they are men, aren't they? And men provide comfort. Every woman feels safe with a real man.
Lastly, but just as important, I read Tennessee Williams' play "Portrait of a Madonna." It's about this woman, who thinks she a high-class respectable lady (which is kind of questionable) and she becomes pregnant out of wedlock. Then she's taken to an insane asylum. It's very sad. Throughout the play, she keeps talking about how often she goes to church and what a respectable lady she is, never has any men. And yet, there is a man in her bedroom. There's a sharp difference between what is really going on on the surface and what the woman thinks of herself and what is going on in her head. It's like there's two different worlds going on at the same time. Well, it's getting late and my fingers are tired of typing, so I'm going to have to cut Tennessee Williams short. His play "Portrait of a Madonna" deserves more than this, but my brain has gone. Goodnight.






